Top of Minneapolis

Minneapolis / Guides / Hidden Gem
The Guide · Hidden Gem

Hidden Gem Restaurants in St. Paul Locals Love (2026)

12rooms ranked
5.6top score
1on the List
August 2026last updated
Kou Thao
By Kou Thao Staff Writer · Top of Minneapolis · Scores from Issue № 137 · How the score is built
Hidden Gem Restaurants in St. Paul Locals Love (2026)

St. Paul rarely needs the word hidden. The city just keeps running its own kitchens without much noise about it, from West Seventh counters to East Side pizza rooms that have never bothered opening a second location. This list stays inside St. Paul proper and names the block every time.

№ 01

Tongue in Cheek

989 Payne Ave, Saint Paul, MN 55130 +16518886148

Tongue in Cheek Photo via Yelp

The Bacon & Egg Teaser and kimchi potato cakes called Vegasm anchor a menu that treats happy hour as a real meal, not a discount afterthought. East Fried Pride rounds out a small plates list built for sharing. The room reads as a reliable date night option where the plating gets noticed as much as the price.

What to orderBacon & Egg Teaser, Vegasm (kimchi potato cakes), East Fried Pride
Scored from the full review record
№ 02

Red Cow St. Paul

393 Selby Ave, St Paul, MN 55102 +16517890545

Red Cow St. Paul Photo via Yelp

The burger and fries are the draw, but the bar seats are where Red Cow works best, close enough to watch the cocktails get built. Part of a small local chain, this location holds the same consistent quality as its siblings. Good for a casual dinner that does not require a reservation.

What to orderburger, fries, craft cocktail
Scored from the full review record
№ 03

Cafe Astoria

180 Grand Ave, Saint Paul, MN 55102 +16515081654

Cafe Astoria Photo via Yelp

A pumpkin spice latte and chocolate croissant pairing has built a following among people squeezing coffee between appointments on West Seventh. The counter moves fast on weekday mornings, and parking around this stretch takes some patience. A dependable stop for espresso rather than a destination in itself.

What to orderpumpkin spice latte, chocolate croissant, espresso
Scored from the full review record
№ 04

Moscow on the Hill

371 Selby Ave, Saint Paul, MN 55102 +16512911236

Moscow on the Hill Photo via Yelp

Beef Stroganoff, pelmeni, and borscht anchor a menu that treats Russian comfort food as the whole point, not a novelty. Service runs warm and fast, the kind of room where regulars get greeted by name. A solid pick for a comfort meal that does not resemble anything else on the street.

What to orderBeef Stroganoff, Pelmeni, Borscht
Scored from the full review record
№ 05

Cecil's

651 Cleveland Ave S, Saint Paul, MN 55116 +16516980334

Cecil's Photo via Yelp

Fresh baked bread greets diners at the door, and the pastrami and corned beef sandwiches justify the wait at the counter in back. Cecil's holds onto a classic deli format that has largely disappeared from the metro. Staff move at an unhurried pace, and regulars treat that as a feature.

What to orderpastrami sandwich, corned beef sandwich, fresh baked bread
Scored from the full review record
№ 06

Brunson's Pub

956 Payne Ave, Saint Paul, MN 55130 +16514472483

Brunson's Pub Photo via Yelp

The patio fills fast on sunny afternoons, and the burger program includes rotating specials like a MN Burger Week single patty with white American and sautéed onion. Pub decor and a full drink list, beer on tap through cocktails, set the tone. Built for a casual group hang more than a quiet dinner.

What to orderMN Burger Week burger, classic burger, craft cocktails
Scored from the full review record
№ 07

Red Rabbit St. Paul

788 Grand Ave, St Paul, MN 55105 +16514445995

Red Rabbit St. Paul Photo via Yelp

The Bianca and salami pizzas lead a menu that also turns out crispy potatoes and a solid house salad, backed by a bar staff that keeps the conversation going. Craft lager and pizza make this a reliable group spot. Execution has been inconsistent lately according to the record, so the pizzas remain the safer order.

What to orderBianca pizza, salami pizza, crispy potatoes
Scored from the full review record
№ 08

The Buttered Tin

237 7th St E, Saint Paul, MN 55101 +16512242300

The Buttered Tin Photo via Yelp

Cinnamon rolls and a breakfast burrito draw the loyal weekend crowd, while the Pig's Eye Breakfast, two eggs, a meat selection, and hash browns, covers the heartier order. Ingredients lean locally sourced. Counter ordering can confuse first timers, but the payoff is a brunch spot that has earned its regulars.

What to ordercinnamon rolls, breakfast burrito, Pig's Eye Breakfast
Scored from the full review record
№ 09

Mama's Pizza

961 Rice St, Saint Paul, MN 55117 +16514892005

Mama's Pizza Photo via Yelp

Red sauce and a loaded everything pizza have kept this East Side room in business for over 45 years, alongside a baked mostaccioli that regulars order in bulk. The room stays plain and unfussy. Longevity alone makes it one of the neighborhood's most trusted pizza counters.

What to orderPizza with everything, Mostaccioli, Flavor Explosion Pizza
Scored from the full review record
№ 10

J. Selby's

169 N Victoria St, St Paul, MN 55104 +16512223263

J. Selby's Photo via Yelp

Loaded fries and a brunch burrito lead an entirely vegan menu built to work for mixed groups, meat eaters included. The kitchen also runs a community fund that helps cover meals for others. A dependable stop for anyone navigating different diets at the same table without splitting into two orders.

What to orderloaded fries, brunch burrito, vegan burger
Scored from the full review record
№ 11

Meritage

5.6Solid

410 St Peter St, Saint Paul, MN 55145 +16512225670

Meritage Photo via Yelp

Steak frites night on Wednesdays remains the move: a fixed price that includes unlimited french fries and a house salad, an unusual value for a room built on Parisian atmosphere. Meritage draws a steady crowd for birthdays and anniversaries, with servers who read the occasion and keep the pacing right for a celebration.

What to ordersteak frites, French fries, house salad
Scored from the full review record
№ 12

Hope Breakfast Bar - St. Paul

1 S Leech St, Saint Paul, MN 55102 +16513308996

Hope Breakfast Bar - St. Paul Photo via Yelp

The carnitas bowl comes generously portioned, a filling anchor to a brunch menu that keeps expanding. The industrial room runs small and can feel packed on weekends, with waits during peak hours, but the drink list gives groups plenty to work through while they wait. Built for a slower weekend meal with friends.

What to orderCarnitas bowl, eggs benedict, pancakes
Scored from the full review record

Frequently asked

What makes a St. Paul restaurant worth listing here instead of a chain?
Every restaurant on this list is independently run and rooted in St. Paul specifically, not a national chain location. The Insider Score reflects the actual review record for that address, and no restaurant pays to be listed.
Where can I find good restaurants near me in St. Paul?
This guide covers rooms spread across St. Paul, from West Seventh to the East Side, so check the neighborhood listed with each entry to find one near you. The Insider Score for each comes straight from the review record, and placement is never paid.
Are any of these restaurants also in Minneapolis?
No. Every restaurant here is located in St. Paul specifically. Red Cow has other locations around the metro, but this entry covers the St. Paul room only.
How is the Insider Score calculated?
The Insider Score is built from the volume and content of real customer reviews for each restaurant. It is not influenced by advertising, and no restaurant pays for placement or a higher score on this guide.
ƒ

The data first, then the verdict

We start with the review record, not a press release. Every room here is a real kitchen with a strong rating across a meaningful number of reviews, ranked on our 10-point Insider Score. We weight consistency over time and the rooms locals return to, not the ones tourists pass through once. The list updates as the data does. How we work →

Kou Thao
Kou Thao
Staff Writer · Top of Minneapolis

Kou Thao is the St. Paul & Corridors Editor at Top of Minneapolis. Born in St. Paul and raised in Frogtown, he grew up working the family egg-roll stand at Hmongtown Marketplace. He covers the marketplaces, University Avenue, the East Side and West Side, and every corridor counter worth the trip across the river.

Five rooms, every Friday.

The new opening, the sleeper the score just flagged, and the one room worth booking this week. Free.