12 Best Restaurants in Plymouth (2026)

The fresh mozzarella pie is the order here, a Margherita build that draws repeat regulars in a room too small to hide its quality. ElMar's runs New York-style crust and honest topping ratios without the theatrics some corner shops lean on. It is counter-simple and unpretentious, and the crust holds its structure through a full slice, which is the whole test.

The buffet is the move at India Palace, a steam line of chicken tikka masala, samosas, and naan that works for a family table without anyone needing to negotiate the menu. The spice level runs mild by default, worth knowing if that matters to the order. It sits in a strip mall and serves a mostly local, repeat crowd.

Tandoori masala and coconut curry pizza put this kitchen in its own category, built around a curry ranch sauce that shows up across the menu. A full vegan section runs separate from the regular list, with chaat fries and garlic naan bites rounding out the order. The room reads more converted food-truck operation than dining room, clean and unfussy on a slow weeknight.

The lunch special is the value play, nigiri and rolls that come out fast and taste fresh for the counter-service price point. Sashimi service can run thin-cut and a little rough on presentation, so the nigiri and rolls are the safer order. The room gets loud and full at peak hours, which suits a quick group lunch better than a quiet one.

Cheese pizza and the white-sauce chicken pizza are the two orders worth driving for, with a cheese bread side that stays intentionally basic rather than loaded. The space skews takeout over sit-down despite table seating, and a recent renovation means shorter waits than the old room saw. A parking lot out front makes the to-go run painless.

The spicy bowl comes generously portioned for a counter-service price, and online ordering makes the customization painless before pickup. Seafood quality reads fresh, though the two-protein bowl is not the best poke in the metro by a wide margin. The tapioca boba side of the menu draws its own following, with large iced coffee milk tea a frequent order.

Dal makhani and tandoori chicken anchor a menu that runs deep and skews toward a local Indian clientele who order with confidence. It is counter service with free parking, and the line can run out the door at dinner, so online ordering ahead is the practical move. The biryani reads as a strong secondary order behind the tandoori standards.

Chaat and dal makhani lead a menu where the payoff is worth navigating an ordering process that trips up first-timers. Tandoori chicken comes out strong once the counter system clicks, and regulars report the effort pays off in the plate. It is a straightforward counter room built for people who already know what they want.

Chicken parmesan and the chicken sandwich are the standing orders at this strip-mall bar and grill, with pizza as a reliable third option. The kitchen runs consistent most visits, though a shortened menu period a while back briefly dented quality before it recovered. It works well as a stop before a movie at nearby Emagine Willow Creek.

Burgers, wings, and fish and chips cover the base of a menu built for group tables and corporate lunch crowds. Service moves fast even without a reservation, seating a table of ten inside minutes on a moderately busy afternoon. The food itself lands closer to reliable than exciting, wide-open room, plenty of space, nothing that misses badly.

The hibachi plate is the reason to book a table here, fried rice and miso soup rounding out a tableside cooking show built for groups and birthday parties. Lunch-menu hibachi runs a smaller portion at a lower price and still delivers on flavor. Wait times stay short even on weeknights, and seating away from the hibachi grill is available for those who want a quieter table.

The fish fry is the reason to show up during Lent, a light batter over fish that holds together rather than falling apart in the fryer. Cheese curds have drawn mixed results, and service can slow when the pub fills for a game. Prices run a bit high for the portion size, but the fish fry alone beat out several competitors in a head-to-head Lenten taste test.